What Actually Makes a Water Softener Good?
A logo doesn't soften water. The valve, resin, tank, flow capacity, sizing, installation and service determine how a system performs. Here's what we look at when evaluating any water softener, including our own.
1. Control valve
The control valve is the brain of the softener. It directs water through the system in service, runs each regeneration step (backwash, brine draw, rinse and refill) and decides when to regenerate.
- Valve
- AWW ProValve, ceramic disc
- Valve flow
- 25.5 GPM
- Memory backup
- 72 hours
- Regeneration trigger
- Demand-initiated (metered)
- Regeneration type
- Upflow counter-current
A ceramic-disc valve uses two hard ceramic discs that rotate against each other to route water. Ceramic is extremely wear-resistant, which is why the discs in our valves carry a lifetime warranty. Piston-style valves are also a proven, widely used design; their seals and spacers are wear parts that may need replacement over the life of the system. Either can work well when properly sized and maintained.
Demand-initiated regeneration means the valve meters actual water use and regenerates only when the resin needs it, instead of on a fixed timer. Upflow counter-current brining sends brine through the resin in the opposite direction of service flow, which generally uses salt more efficiently.
2. Resin
Softening resin is made of small plastic beads that hold sodium ions. As hard water passes through, calcium and magnesium swap places with the sodium. That is ion exchange. Regeneration flushes the beads with brine to recharge them.
- Resin
- CG10
- Type
- Strong-acid cation
- Crosslinking
- 10%
- Resin
- CG10
Crosslinking describes how tightly the resin beads are bonded internally. Higher crosslinking makes beads more resistant to oxidation from chlorine and chloramine, which slowly break resin down over time. That matters on disinfected city water like El Paso's. Standard 8% resin works well in many homes; 10% resin is chosen for durability where disinfectants are present. A 10% resin does not automatically make every system better, since sizing, valve and installation matter as much.
3. Carbon
- Carbon
- Granular activated coconut-shell carbon
- Source
- Coconut shell
Carbon does a different job than resin.
- Resin removes hardness.
- Carbon reduces chlorine, taste and odor, plus some organic contaminants depending on the media and contact time. Chloramine is harder to reduce than chlorine and needs more contact time.
Our City Water FilterSoft Pro and XL combine resin and carbon in one mixed bed. The Dual Tank system gives each its own tank. Learn more about whole-house filtration.
4. Tank
- Tank
- Fiberglass pressure tank, 10 × 60
- Assembled in
- Fort Worth, Texas
- Warranty
- Lifetime
The pressure tank holds the resin and carbon under household water pressure. A fiberglass-wrapped tank resists corrosion and is rated for continuous pressure.
5. Flow rate
- Valve flow rate (FilterSoft Pro and XL)
- 25.5 GPM
Flow rate is how much softened water the system can deliver at once without a noticeable pressure drop. It matters most when several fixtures run together: two showers, a washing machine and a kitchen faucet can easily add up to 10 gallons per minute or more. An undersized valve or tank can leave upstairs showers weak during peak use.
6. Correct sizing
| System | Capacity | Tank | Typical fit |
|---|---|---|---|
| City Water FilterSoft Pro | 36,000 grains | 10 × 60 | Most homes up to 3 bathrooms |
| City Water FilterSoft Pro XL | 48,000 grains | 12 × 58 | 4+ bathrooms or 8+ residents |
| Dual Tank City Water FilterSoft MAX | 48,000 grains, dedicated resin + dedicated carbon tanks | Two 10 × 60 | Very large households, pools, high or continuous demand |
Number of bathrooms helps estimate peak flow demand. Household size and water use affect how often the system regenerates. A system that is too small regenerates constantly; one that is too large can sit too long between regenerations. See the City Water FilterSoft Pro and City Water FilterSoft Pro XL spec sheets, or the water softener page.
7. Installation
Even excellent equipment can perform poorly if it is installed or programmed incorrectly. A good installation covers:
- Correct tie-in to the main line
- Bypass
- Drain
- Electrical
- Programming
- Hardness setting
- Leak testing
- Pressure and flow considerations
- Customer walkthrough
Applicable certifications are held by the individual components and media and their respective manufacturers. The assembled Honest Water system is not separately NSF-certified as a complete system.
See exactly what's inside our systems.
Every component, spec and price, published.
